Palestine is not a Quagmire

The metaphors that attempt to render Palestine complicated obscure the simple brutality of Zionist colonization.

Palestine is not a minefield.  Palestine is not complicated.  Palestine is not a morass.  Palestine is not tricky.  Palestine is not a quagmire.  

Palestine is not almost impossible to navigate. 

Continue reading “Palestine is not a Quagmire”

The Muslim Zionists

A generation of compradors has learned that Palestinians are valuable raw material for careerism.

A few days ago, I finally managed to synthesize an observation that has bothered me for decades:  “Being an asshole to Palestinians is an excellent way to launch a media career in the United States.”  From Martin Peretz to Bari Weiss, the strategy has rarely failed writers seeking bylines in prestigious newspapers. 

Continue reading “The Muslim Zionists”

Does It Matter If Israel Annexes the West Bank?

Annexation is bad news, but we should understand it as a material expression of Zionism.

Annexation of the West Bank isn’t a new idea.  Zionists always had their eye on what they call Judea and Samaria, the actual sites of biblical significance as opposed to the coastal and desert areas they conquered in 1948.  As soon as Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan in 1967, its leaders began discussing annexation. 

In fact, Netanyahu’s effort isn’t much different from Yigal Allon’s 1967 proposal (the so-called Allon Plan).  It’s still not clear exactly how the Israeli government will proceed—apparently it intends to annex Area C, including the Jordan Valley, although some officials reportedly want to claim the entire West Bank—but the idea is to make a viable Palestinian state impossible, in keeping with Allon’s vision. 

Continue reading “Does It Matter If Israel Annexes the West Bank?”

How Bernie Sanders Became a Fighter for Palestine

On the importance of mythology to presidential campaigns

With the Democratic primary in full swing, the outlines of public debate are pretty much entrenched.  Common wisdom on the left says that all of the candidates are bad on Palestine except for Bernie Sanders.  Despite some problems, pundits declare, Sanders is still the best.  Is the statement true, though, or is it a convenient truism? 

Continue reading “How Bernie Sanders Became a Fighter for Palestine”

The Magical City of Jerusalem

“Where are you from?” For Palestinians, it can be a devastating question.

The other day I was browsing the July issue of Palestine in America (an excellent magazine) featuring a profile of fashion designer Rami Kashou.  Kashou is best known for his appearance on season 4 of Project Runway (2007-08), a design competition in which he placed second.  He went on to a successful career in fashion. 

Although I didn’t follow Kashou’s career, I remember him well.  My wife and I liked Project Runway in its heyday and were watching when Kashou was introduced.  His accent, his body language, his facial features—all felt deeply familiar.  We glanced at each other.  “Gotta be,” she said.  The energy in the room got happier.  We would have the rare opportunity to cheer on a Palestinian contestant. 

Continue reading “The Magical City of Jerusalem”

Renouncing Israel on Principle

How to answer the question, “Do you affirm Israel’s right to exist?”

When anti-Zionists discuss the Middle East, the topic of Israel’s existence rarely arises.  It’s almost exclusively a pro-Israel talking point.  We’re focused on national liberation, on surviving repression, on strategies of resistance, on recovering subjugated histories, on the complex (and sometimes touchy) relationships among an Indigenous population disaggregated by decades of aggression.  That a colonial state—or any state, really—possesses no ontological rights is an unspoken assumption. 

Continue reading “Renouncing Israel on Principle”

The Unlocked Turnstile of Palestine Solidarity

At what point can Palestinians trust former Zionists?

Around a year-and-a-half ago, I received an email from Mira Sucharov, a professor at Carleton University, inviting me to join a conference roundtable, “Israel-Palestine Scholarship, Activism, and the Threat to Academic Freedom.”  The request was polite and professional and the topic seemed fine (though the term “Israel-Palestine” always give me pause).  A day later, I declined the invitation. 

Continue reading “The Unlocked Turnstile of Palestine Solidarity”

The Big Picture

Settling into life as an ex-academic also means fighting off the aftereffects of academe.

When I was learning to be a school bus driver, our instructors talked often of the big picture.  It was especially common during on-the-road training.  An instructor would lean across the aisle and point to the windshield.  “Remember the big picture.”  Something abnormal or noteworthy was ahead. 

The big picture was meant to sharpen perception of roadway unpredictability:  low-hanging branches, potholes, lane mergers, road construction, accidents, broken stoplights, standing water, fallen wires, erratic drivers.  We were being trained to avoid problems through early detection. 

Continue reading “The Big Picture”

Hamza Yusuf and the Religion of Palestine

Bad things happen when Palestine is treated as a symbolic geography rather than a site of material struggle.

Sheikh Hamza Yusuf was recently in the news again.  Yusuf, born Mark Hanson in 1958, is probably the best-known Muslim leader in the USA.  (I know the word “leader” is loaded, so substitute “cleric” or “theologian” or “scholar” or “imam” or “hype man” if you wish.)  Controversy is an inevitable feature of that position, so a journey through the social media cycle isn’t unusual, but Yusuf exhibits a talent for empty provocation.  A good controversy pushes people to rethink common assumptions; those provoked by Yusuf impose orthodoxy on audiences who crave daring and meaningful ideas. 

Continue reading “Hamza Yusuf and the Religion of Palestine”

A Ten Step Guide to Exploiting Palestine on the Western Left

Proven to enhance your appeal as a potential guest on liberal programming and facilitate your quest for social media celebrity.

1. Constantly promote people who are more influential, even (or especially) if their politics are to your right.  These luminaries will preferably belong to your own socio-economic class; if not, with a proper effort, you’ll soon belong to theirs. 

2. Occasionally say something decent about Palestine, a signal that you’re hip to the militant stuff, but save your most serious commentary for explaining why Bernie Sanders is the logical heir to George Habash.

Continue reading “A Ten Step Guide to Exploiting Palestine on the Western Left”